Mendel’s Experiments and Punnett Squares

Lesson Content

Inquire: Mendel’s Experiments and the Laws of Probability

Overview

Genetics is the science of heredity. Austrian monk Gregor Mendel set the framework for genetics long before chromosomes or genes had been identified, even at a time when meiosis was not well understood. Working with garden peas, Mendel found that crosses between true-breeding parents (P) that differed in one trait produced first generation (F1) offspring that all expressed the trait of one parent. Mendel used the term dominant to refer to the trait that was observed, and recessive to denote that non-expressed trait, or the trait that had “disappeared” in this first generation. When the F1 offspring were crossed with each other, the F2 offspring exhibited both traits in a 3:1 ratio. Other crosses generated the same 3:1 ratio in the F2 offspring. By mathematically examining sample sizes, Mendel showed that genetic crosses behaved according to the laws of probability, and that the traits were inherited as independent events. In other words, Mendel used statistical methods to build his model of inheritance.

Decorative

Big Question

Why was Mendel’s experimental work so successful?

Watch: The Work of Gregor Mendel

Read: Mendel’s Experiments and Punnett Squares

Overview

DecorativeMendel’s seminal work was accomplished using the garden pea to study inheritance. This species naturally self-fertilizes, such that pollen encounters ova within individual flowers. The flower petals remain sealed tightly until after pollination, preventing pollination from other plants. The result is highly inbred, or “true-breeding,” pea plants. These are plants that always produce offspring that look like the parent. By experimenting with true-breeding pea plants, Mendel avoided the appearance of unexpected traits in offspring that might occur if the plants were not true-breeding. The garden pea also grows to maturity within one season, meaning that several generations could be evaluated over a relatively short time. Finally, large quantities of garden peas could be cultivated simultaneously, allowing Mendel to conclude that his results did not come about simply by chance.

Mendelian Crosses

Mendel performed hybridizations, which involve mating two true-breeding individuals that have different traits. In the pea, this is done by manually transferring pollen from the anther of a mature pea plant of one variety to the stigma of a separate mature pea plant of the second variety. In plants, pollen carries the male gametes (sperm) to the stigma, a sticky organ that traps pollen and allows the sperm to move down the pistil to the female gametes (ova) below. To prevent the pea plant that was receiving pollen from self-fertilizing and confounding his results, Mendel painstakingly removed all of the anthers from the plant’s flowers before they had a chance to mature.

DecorativePlants used in first-generation crosses were called P0, or parental generation one. After each cross, Mendel collected the seeds belonging to the P0 plants and grew them the following season. These offspring were called the F1, or the first filial (filial = offspring, daughter or son) generation. Once Mendel examined the characteristics in the F1 generation of plants, he allowed them to self-fertilize naturally. He then collected and grew the seeds from the F1 plants to produce the F2, or second filial, generation. Mendel’s experiments extended beyond the F2 generation to the F3 and F4 generations, and so on, but it was the ratio of characteristics in the P0−F1−F2 generations that were the most intriguing and became the basis for Mendel’s postulates.

Garden Pea Characteristics Revealed the Basics of Heredity

In his 1865 publication, Mendel reported the results of his crosses involving seven different characteristics, each with two contrasting traits. A trait is defined as a variation in the physical appearance of a heritable characteristic. The characteristics included plant height, seed texture, seed color, flower color, pea pod size, pea pod color, and flower position. For the characteristic of flower color, for example, the two contrasting traits were white versus violet. To fully examine each characteristic, Mendel generated large numbers of F1 and F2 plants, reporting results from 19,959 F2 plants alone. His findings were consistent.

First, Mendel confirmed that he had plants that bred true for white or violet flower color. Regardless of how many generations Mendel examined, all self-crossed offspring of parents with white flowers had white flowers, and all self-crossed offspring of parents with violet flowers had violet flowers. In addition, Mendel confirmed that, other than flower color, the pea plants were physically identical.

Once these validations were complete, Mendel applied the pollen from a plant with violet flowers to the stigma of a plant with white flowers. After gathering and sowing the seeds that resulted from this cross, Mendel found that 100 percent of the F1 hybrid generation had violet flowers. Conventional wisdom at that time would have predicted the hybrid flowers to be pale violet or for hybrid plants to have equal numbers of white and violet flowers. Mendel’s results demonstrated that the white flower trait in the F1 generation had completely disappeared.

Importantly, Mendel did not stop his experimentation there. He allowed the F1 plants to self-fertilize and found that, of F2-generation plants, 705 had violet flowers and 224 had white flowers. This was a ratio of 3.15 violet flowers per one white flower, or approximately 3:1. When Mendel transferred pollen from a plant with violet flowers to the stigma of a plant with white flowers and vice versa, he obtained about the same ratio regardless of which parent, male or female, contributed which trait. This is called a reciprocal cross — a paired cross in which the respective traits of the male and female in one cross become the respective traits of the female and male in the other cross. For the other six characteristics Mendel examined, the F1 and F2 generations behaved in the same way as they had for flower color. One of the two traits would disappear completely from the F1 generation only to reappear in the F2 generation at a ratio of approximately 3:1.

Upon compiling his results, Mendel concluded that the characteristics could be divided into expressed (dominant) and latent (recessive) traits. Dominant traits are those that are inherited unchanged in a hybridization. Recessive traits become latent, or disappear, in the offspring of a hybridization. The recessive trait does, however, reappear in the progeny of the hybrid offspring. An example of a dominant trait is the violet-flower trait. For this same characteristic, white-colored flowers are a recessive trait. The fact that the recessive trait reappeared in the F2 generation meant that the traits remained separate in the plants of the F1 generation. Mendel also proposed that plants possessed two copies of the trait for the flower-color characteristic, and that each parent transmitted one of its two copies to its offspring, where they came together.

Reflect: A Decade of Research?

Poll

Gregor Mendel’s research was a decade-long pursuit. Why do you think he would spend a decade of his life researching pea plants?

Expand: Creating a Punnett Square

Discover

DecorativeTo understand the laws of probability used to predict the outcome of cross-breeding, you can visualize it by creating what is called a Punnett square. To prepare a Punnett square, all possible combinations of the parental alleles are listed along the top (for one parent) and side (for the other parent) of a grid, representing their meiotic segregation into haploid gametes. Then the combinations of egg and sperm are written in the table’s boxes to show which alleles are combining. Each box then represents the diploid genotype of a zygote, or fertilized egg, that could result from the specific mating. Because each possibility is equally likely, genotypic ratios can be determined from a Punnett square. If the pattern of inheritance is known, the phenotypic ratios can be inferred as well. For a monohybrid cross of two true-breeding parents, each parent contributes one type of allele. In the following example, only one genotype is possible. All offspring are Yy and have yellow seeds.

In this second example, the P generation, pea plants that are true-breeding for the dominant yellow phenotype, are crossed with plants with the recessive green phenotype. This cross produces F1 heterozygotes with a yellow phenotype. Punnett square analysis can be used to predict the genotypes of the F2 generation. A self-cross of one of the Yy heterozygous offspring can be represented in a 2 × 2 Punnett square because each parent can donate one of two different alleles. Therefore, the offspring can potentially have one of four allele combinations: YY, Yy, yY, or yy. Notice that there are two ways to obtain the Yy genotype: a Y from the egg and a y from the sperm, or a y from the egg and a Y from the sperm. Both of these possibilities must be counted.

DecorativeRecall that Mendel’s pea-plant characteristics behaved in the same way in reciprocal crosses. Therefore, the two possible heterozygous combinations produce offspring that are genotypically and phenotypically identical despite their dominant and recessive alleles deriving from different parents. They are grouped together. Because fertilization is a random event, we expect each combination to be equally likely and for the offspring to exhibit a ratio of YY:Yy:yy genotypes of 1:2:1. Furthermore, because the YY and Yy offspring have yellow seeds and are phenotypically identical, applying the sum rule of probability, we expect the offspring to exhibit a phenotypic ratio of 3 yellow:1 green. Indeed, working with large sample sizes, Mendel observed approximately this ratio in every F2 generation resulting from crosses for individual traits.

Check Your Knowledge

Use the quiz below to check your understanding of this lesson’s content. You can take this quiz as many times as you like. Once you are finished taking the quiz, click on the “View questions” button to review the correct answers.

Lesson Resources

Lesson Toolbox

Additional Resources and Readings

Monohybrids and the Punnett Square Guinea Pigs

An Amoeba Sisters video covering Punnett squares and genetic probabilities

Mendel Pea Simulation

A simulation of Mendel’s pea plant experiment

Pea Soup

An interactive pea experiment where you can breed your own hybrid pea plants

How Punnett Squares Work

A video that explains how Punnett squares work

Lesson Glossary

Terms

AJAX progress indicator
  • F1
    first filial generation in a cross; the offspring of the parental generation
  • F2
    second filial generation produced when F1 individuals are self-crossed or fertilized with each other
  • genotype
    underlying genetic makeup, consisting of both physically visible and non-expressed alleles, of an organism
  • heterozygous
    having two different alleles for a given gene on the homologous chromosome
  • hybridizations
    process of mating two individuals that differ with the goal of achieving a certain characteristic in their offspring
  • P0
    parental generation in a cross
  • phenotype
    observable traits expressed by an organism
  • Punnett square
    visual representation of a cross between two individuals in which the gametes of each individual are denoted along the top and side of a grid, respectively, and the possible zygotic genotypes are recombined at each box in the grid
  • recessive
    trait that appears “latent” or non-expressed when the individual also carries a dominant trait for that same characteristic; when present as two identical copies, the recessive trait is expressed
  • reciprocal cross
    paired cross in which the respective traits of the male and female in one cross become the respective traits of the female and male in the other cross
  • trait
    variation in the physical appearance of a heritable characteristic

License and Citations

Content License

Lesson Content:

Authored and curated by Jill Carson for The TEL Library. CC BY NC SA 4.0

Adapted Content:

Title: Biology – 12.1 Mendel’s Experiments and Laws of Probability – Mendel’s Model System: Rice University, OpenStax CNX. License: CC BY 4.0

Title: Biology – 12.2 Characteristics and Traits – Phenotypes and Genotypes; The Punnett Square Approach for a Monohybrid Cross: Rice University, OpenStax CNX. License: CC BY 4.0

Media Sources

 LinkAuthorPublisherLicense
DecorativeMan Dna SpiralNeuPaddyPixabayCC 0
DecorativePSM V84 D010 The mechanism of heredity fig1T.H. MorganWikimedia CommonsPublic Domain
DecorativeFigure 2. Monohybrid CrossOpenStaxOpenStaxCC BY 4.0
DecorativeFigure 2. inheritance patternsOpenStaxOpenStaxCC BY 4.0
DecorativeFigure 1. Johann Gregor MendelOpenStaxOpenStaxCC BY 4.0